RCD vs RCBO vs AFDD: Which Does Your Consumer Unit Need?
Last updated 21 November 2026
An RCD protects against electric shock by switching off when it detects current leaking to earth. An RCBO combines that RCD protection with a circuit breaker for a single circuit, so a fault only switches off that circuit. An AFDD detects dangerous arcing that could start a fire. Under BS 7671, most circuits in a home need RCD protection, and AFDDs are required on certain socket circuits in higher risk buildings and recommended elsewhere.
Open the door of a modern consumer unit and you will see a row of switches that look almost identical. Some are circuit breakers, some are RCDs, some are RCBOs and, increasingly, some are AFDDs. They do different jobs, they cost different amounts and the wiring regulations treat them differently. This guide explains each one in plain terms, what BS 7671 currently asks for, and how to work out what your own consumer unit needs. It is written for homes and rented property in England.
The current version of the wiring regulations
The national standard for electrical installations in the UK is BS 7671, the IET Wiring Regulations. The 18th Edition was first published in 2018 and has been amended several times since. According to the IET, Amendment 4 (BS 7671:2018+A4:2026) is now the current version, and the transition period for Amendment 2 ended on 15 October 2026. Most of the rules about RCDs and AFDDs that people talk about date from Amendment 2 in 2022, and they carry forward into Amendment 4.
BS 7671 is not retrospective. An installation that met the edition in force when it was put in is not automatically unsafe because the rules have moved on, and you are not legally required to upgrade it just because a new amendment is published. What changes is the standard that new work, alterations and periodic inspections are measured against.
The three devices in plain English
RCD: protection against electric shock
A residual current device compares the current flowing out along the line conductor with the current coming back along the neutral. In a healthy circuit the two match. If some current is escaping to earth, perhaps through a damaged cable, a faulty appliance or a person, the RCD sees the imbalance and disconnects in a fraction of a second. The devices used for additional protection in homes trip at 30 mA or less.
On its own, an RCD does not protect against overload or short circuit. In many consumer units one RCD sits at the head of a group of circuits, with an ordinary circuit breaker (MCB) for each circuit underneath it. That is cheaper to build, but every circuit in the group shares the same RCD, so a leak on one switches them all off.
RCBO: an RCD and a circuit breaker in one
An RCBO combines the RCD function with the overload and short circuit protection of an MCB, in a single device serving a single circuit. Each circuit gets its own earth leakage protection. If the kitchen sockets develop a fault, only the kitchen sockets go off, while the lights, the fridge freezer and the alarm stay on. It also makes faults quicker to trace, because the device that tripped tells you which circuit to look at.
AFDD: protection against fire from arcing
An arc fault detection device looks for something neither an RCD nor an MCB is designed to spot: arcing. Arcs happen at loose terminals, in cables crushed under furniture or pierced by a nail, and in worn appliance flexes. The current involved can be too small to trip a breaker and may not leak to earth at all, so an RCD will not react, yet the heat can be enough to start a fire. An AFDD analyses the shape of the current and disconnects the circuit when it recognises the signature of an arc. Many AFDDs made for UK consumer units combine arc detection with RCBO protection in one device, and BS 7671 says an AFDD must be placed at the origin of the circuit it protects, which in a home means in the consumer unit.
Where BS 7671 requires RCD protection
In a home, 30 mA RCD protection is now expected on almost every circuit. In summary, the regulations call for it on:
- socket-outlets rated up to 32 A;
- mobile equipment rated up to 32 A for use outdoors;
- circuits supplying light fittings in domestic premises;
- cables buried in a wall or partition less than 50 mm from the surface, unless they have an earthed metal covering or mechanical protection;
- every circuit in a room containing a bath or shower.
Outside dwellings, there is a narrow exception for socket-outlets where a documented risk assessment shows RCD protection is not necessary. That exception does not apply in homes.
The regulations do not say whether the protection must come from RCDs or RCBOs. Both satisfy the requirement. The choice is about how the protection is arranged. BS 7671 also requires an installation to be divided so that a fault causes as little danger and inconvenience as possible, and so that unwanted tripping is avoided, which is why a single RCD covering every circuit in the house is rarely fitted on new work.
Choosing the right type of RCD
RCDs and RCBOs come in types that describe what kind of leakage they can detect, and this matters more now than it did ten years ago:
- Type AC detects plain alternating leakage only. Since Amendment 2, BS 7671 restricts Type AC devices to fixed equipment where the load is known not to produce any DC component, which rules them out for general circuits in most homes.
- Type A also detects pulsating DC leakage, which electronic equipment such as LED drivers, induction hobs and many modern appliances can produce. This is the usual choice for household circuits.
- Type F adds detection of mixed-frequency leakage from equipment with variable-speed motors, such as some washing machines and heat pumps.
- Type B detects smooth DC leakage as well, and is used for some EV chargers, solar inverters and battery systems where the equipment does not have its own DC fault protection.
If your existing unit has Type AC devices, it does not mean you are in danger. An inspector may record it as a C3, improvement recommended, and a Type AC device is not normally the right choice for new work.
Where AFDDs are required, and where they are only recommended
AFDDs first appeared in BS 7671 in 2018 as a recommendation. Amendment 2 turned that into a requirement for single-phase final circuits supplying socket-outlets rated up to 32 A in four kinds of building:
- high rise residential buildings;
- houses in multiple occupation (HMOs);
- purpose-built student accommodation;
- care homes.
For every other type of premises, including an ordinary family house or a flat let to a single household, AFDDs on socket-outlet circuits are recommended rather than required.
If you let an HMO, this is the part that most often catches landlords out. When socket circuits are added or altered, or the consumer unit is replaced, the new work has to meet the current requirement, so AFDDs should be part of the design. For an existing HMO that predates the requirement, Electrical Safety First's Best Practice Guide 4 classifies the absence of AFDDs as C3, so it does not on its own make a periodic report unsatisfactory. In other homes, the same guide treats a missing AFDD as an observation only, with no code at all.
So which does my consumer unit need?
There is no single answer, because it depends on the property, how it is used and what is connected to it. As a rough guide:
- A typical owner-occupied house or flat. Every circuit needs 30 mA RCD protection. That can be provided by a dual RCD board or by an RCBO on each circuit. AFDDs are optional but worth discussing, particularly for bedrooms and living areas, or where there are older appliances and a lot of extension leads in use.
- A home let to one household. The same as above. Being rented does not change what BS 7671 asks for, but RCBOs make life easier for tenants, because one faulty appliance will not leave the whole property without power and prompt an emergency call.
- An HMO, student let or care home. RCD protection as above, plus AFDDs on the socket-outlet circuits for any new or replacement work.
- A home with an EV charger, heat pump, solar panels or a battery. Check that the RCD type suits each piece of equipment, as described above, and that the board has the space and capacity for the extra circuits.
Your electrician should also look at surge protection, which BS 7671 now expects in most installations, and at whether the enclosure meets the requirement for a non-combustible consumer unit in a home.
Cost implications
The price of any consumer unit work depends on the number of circuits and the condition of the existing wiring, so always ask for a written quote. The way the choice of device affects that price is easier to explain:
- RCD boards cost the least to build. A dual RCD board uses two RCDs to cover all the circuits, with simple MCBs underneath, so there are fewer of the more expensive devices.
- RCBOs cost more per circuit. Each circuit needs its own RCBO, so a board with ten circuits has ten of them. The extra cost buys fewer whole-house power cuts and quicker fault finding, and many households feel it is money well spent.
- AFDDs are typically the most expensive device per circuit. A combined AFDD and RCBO costs considerably more than an RCBO, and some designs are wider, which can mean a larger enclosure. Fitting them only where they are required or most useful keeps the cost down.
- The RCD type matters too. Type B devices typically cost a lot more than Type A, so they are normally limited to the circuits that need them.
- Retrofitting is not always simple. You cannot always clip a new RCBO or AFDD into an older consumer unit. Devices should be compatible with the enclosure they are fitted in, and Best Practice Guide 4 flags mixed brands of device that have not been verified by the manufacturer. If the existing board is old, full of Type AC devices or has no spare space, replacing the whole unit is often better value than adding parts to it.
- Faults found along the way add to the job. A new board should only be connected to circuits that test satisfactorily, so earthing, bonding or cable problems discovered during the work have to be put right first.
Testing what you already have
RCDs, RCBOs and many AFDDs have a test button. Pressing it should switch the device off. It proves the mechanism works, not that the device trips at the right current, so it is no substitute for the instrument tests carried out during an inspection. Follow the manufacturer's instructions on how often to press it, and if a device does not trip, have it checked. Many AFDDs also have an indicator that shows why they tripped, which helps an electrician tell an arc fault from an earth leakage or an overload.
Get advice for your property
If you are not sure what your consumer unit has, or whether it suits the way you use your home, an inspection will tell you. An EICR records the protective device on every circuit and tests whether it works, and our guide to consumer unit upgrades explains what happens on the day if a replacement is the right answer. Landlords can read Can you fail an EICR? to see how these devices are coded on a report.
We carry out consumer unit upgrades as part of our domestic electrical work across Blackpool, the Fylde, Preston, Kirkham, Garstang, Over Wyre and Fleetwood. Call 01253 364101, or use our contact page to tell us about your property and the options you are considering.
Frequently asked questions
Is an RCBO better than an RCD?
Both give the same 30 mA protection against electric shock. An RCBO protects a single circuit, so a fault only switches off that circuit, while an RCD usually protects a group of circuits. RCBOs cost more per circuit but are more convenient and make faults easier to find.
Are AFDDs a legal requirement in my house?
Not in an ordinary house or flat. BS 7671 requires AFDDs on socket-outlet circuits up to 32 A in high rise residential buildings, HMOs, purpose-built student accommodation and care homes, and recommends them everywhere else.
Will my EICR be unsatisfactory if my consumer unit has no AFDDs?
No. Best Practice Guide 4 classifies missing AFDDs as C3 in the four types of building where they are required, and as an observation only in other homes. Neither makes the report unsatisfactory.
Can I just swap my RCD for RCBOs?
Sometimes, if the consumer unit is designed to take them and there is space. Devices need to be compatible with the enclosure, so an electrician should check before anything is changed, and the work should be certified.
What does Type AC mean on an RCD?
It is a device that only detects plain alternating leakage. Modern electronics can produce leakage it cannot see, so BS 7671 now limits Type AC devices to specific fixed equipment. Most household circuits use Type A or better.
What does AFDD stand for?
AFDD stands for Arc Fault Detection Device. It monitors a circuit for the electrical signature of arcing, such as from a damaged cable or a loose connection, and switches the circuit off before the arcing can start a fire.
Does an AFDD replace an RCD or RCBO?
No. An AFDD protects against fire from arcing, while an RCD or RCBO protects against electric shock and earth faults. Combined devices are available that provide AFDD and RCBO protection in one unit.
Do I need an AFDD on every circuit?
No. BS 7671 requires them on certain socket circuits in specific types of building and recommends them for other circuits. Whether they are worth fitting elsewhere in your home is something to discuss with your electrician.
Sources
- IET, Ensure you are up to date with BS 7671https://electrical.theiet.org/bs-7671-18th-edition-wiring-regulations/ensure-you-are-up-to-date-with-bs-7671/
- BEAMA, What's new for Arc Fault Detection Devices (AFDDs) in BS 7671:2018+A2:2022https://www.beama.org.uk/static/60aec0d0-e6c8-4ca9-b486fb8a843d0c55/AFDD-fact-sheet-3-BS-7671-AMD2.pdf
- Electrical Safety First, Best Practice Guide 4: Electrical Installation Condition Reportinghttps://niceic.com/getmedia/1acf8e45-b5a1-40ed-b066-d5f18674f99e/best-practice-guide-4-issue-7.pdf
